On Fracturing Fairy Tales

WELCOME TO MY NEW WEBSITE

This is a blog I wrote for the Children’s Book Council of Australia (Tasmania) following the launch of my latest book, The Smallest Carbon Footprint in the Land & Other Ecotales at Hobart Bookshop on 11 April 2013.

Ecotales Launch. Photo by Ralph Wessman
The Launch of The Smallest Carbon Footprint in the Land & Other Ecotales, Hobart Bookshop, 11 April 2013. Photo Ralph Wessman.

On Fracturing Fairy Tales

Once upon a time there were no computer games, movies, televisions or printed books. In those days only voices told stories. Stories swirled around in the smoke of campfires and stone hearths and chimneys, changing shape according to the imagination, narrative skill and world view of every teller. Stories were told to pass the time. To make sense of birth, death and everything in between. To amuse children and to caution them about the dangers of certain behaviours.

The archaic tales were often set in dream-like, magical lands which were populated not only by humans, but by talking animals and objects, as well as witches, wizards, fairies, elves, trolls, giants, ogres, pookas, mermaids, selkies, undines, leprechauns and other ethereal, creepy or downright evil characters.

Over generations, favourite stories passed into folk lore. And with the advent of the publishing industry, ‘fairy tales’ began to be written down and published. As early as 1697, Charles Perrault saw the publication of his delightful French fairy tales (Histoires ou contes du temps passé). Soon afterwards, his countryman, Antoine Galland,

translated a collection of Middle Eastern tales known as the Thousand and One Nights (Les Mille et Une Nuits, contes arabes traduit en français, 1704-1712). In 1812 the German academics, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, brought out Kinder-und Hausmärchen (commonly translated as Tales from the Brothers Grimm). Hans Christian Andersen, a prolific inventor of Danish fairy tales, had his ‘Eventyr’ published between 1835 and 1872. In 1887 ‘Speranza’, also known as Lady Jane Wilde (mother of Oscar Wilde), recorded the fairy tales of Ireland in Ancient Legends, Mystic Charms and Superstitions of Ireland while more recently, Iona and Peter Opie collected and edited The Classic Fairy Tales, 1974. The study and interpretation of fairy and folk tales is now an academic discipline as dense, surprising and foreboding as a medieval forest. Theoreticians including Sir James George Frazer (The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religions, 1890), Joseph Campbell (The Hero with a Thousand Faces, 1949) and Bruno Bettelheim (The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Interpretation of Fairy Tales, 1976) have all recognised that deep mythical, psychic, sexual and political meanings lie below the surface of fairy tales.

The following well-known fairy tales, for example, can be seen to embed messages about gender, patriarchy, class and/or colonialism which may regarded as somewhat less palatable today than they were in ages past:

The Frog Prince and Beauty & the Beast: Girls, don’t kick up a fuss if your father marries you off to a toad or a beast because your new husband may turn out to be a handsome prince in disguise. Cinderella Just grin and bear it, girls, even when forced into domestic slavery; because if you do, your fairy godmother may one day appear and help to arrange a fairy tale wedding for you.

Little Red Riding Hood: Always stick to the straight and narrow, girls, because if you don’t you could be led astray by a Big Bad Wolf who may fool you into thinking he is as sweet and innocent as your granny.

Jack and the Beanstalk and Goldilocks There is no need to despair if you are poor, dim-witted, or prone to walking into other people’s houses and helping yourself to whatever takes your fancy. There are other lands which are rife for the plundering. But flesh-eating bears and ogres live there, so you had better be nimble and quick when you steal their food or treasures and break whatever they hold dear.

When Samuel Johnson completed his Dictionary of the English Language he fixed the previously fluid spelling of the English language to an England of 1755. Yet his, and all other the other subsequent dictionaries, needed to be constantly updated because the meanings of words shift around; new words and phrases enter the common vocabulary while others become obsolete. Similarly, fairy tales are constantly being told and retold for sheer pleasure, or because writers, publishers, parents, educators or guardians of public morality want to change the messages encoded within them.

Nihilism of any sort, along with references to sexual acts or pregnancy, or to overt violence and death, have been expurgated from the texts of most earlier fairy tales.

Over time, the protagonists of fairy tales have been granted happy-ever-after endings, which are seen as more suitable for children than some of the more gruesome endings of some earlier texts. In the twentieth and

early twenty-first centuries, fairy tales have been further exposed to a smiley-faced homogenisation by the ever-popular Walt Disney film studios.

Yet there is no denying the childish, yet universal, appeal of the archetypal plots of fairy tales and the attraction of their naïve, astute, funny and downright wicked characters. This is why fairy tales, with their imaginative qualities, their psychological significance and ability to convey encoded messages, have always sparked the interests of writers, educators, parents and the guardians of public morality.

Perhaps as a reaction to the progressive bowdlerisation of fairy tales, Roald Dahl, the foremost writer of children’s stories of his day, applied his funny, wicked and subversive wit to fairy tales. When he brought out his

Revolting Rhymes in 1982 he became a forerunner of what is now a recognised sub-genre of children’s literature, the ‘fractured fairy tale.’

ON WRITING THE ECOTALES

During a heated exchange on climate change at a dinner party I hosted a couple of years ago I received a call from my muse to fracture a fairy tale. Instead of an acorn falling on Chicken Licken’s head, a wave could splash over him, and he could sound the alarm that the sea level is rising.

All the stock characters in the climate change debate can be found in that fairy tale. There is the curious chicken who wants to know why the sea level is rising and how to stop it from rising any further. Turkey Lurkey could bury her head in the sand. The geese and ducks could thoughtlessly and quack out Chicken Licken’s alarm. Foxie Loxie could be the climate denier who tries to lure the birds into a boat and eat them up. Jowly Owly could be the climate change expert who explains the carbon cycle to them. And Farmer King and his fine feathered friends could work out how to minimise carbon pollution on their farm by the sea. Thank you, Muse!

Messy Lox
Space Cadet Messy Lox illustration by Gay McKinnon.

Inspired by the cosmologists’ ‘Goldilocks Theory’ (life evolved on Earth because the conditions were JUST RIGHT!). I then wrote Messy Lox Goes to the Planet of the Bears, a futuristic ecotale about a young space cadet who sails her space bug around the Ursa Minor (Little Bear) galaxy, visiting a large planet which is too hot, a medium-sized planet which is too cold, and a baby planet which is JUST RIGHT! She starts to pollute the environment of the baby planet until three bears let her know exactly what they think of humans and their pollution.

The tide of inspiration kept flooding in. Because ‘Cindy’ is kept locked up by her wicked step family, she must have the smallest carbon footprint in the land. Why not give her diamond slippers, since diamond is the hardest form of carbon? She could be kitted out for the ball by a fairy godmother who works in an op shop and she could marry a prince who is potty about organic gardening.

Bling could be the genie of Consumerism. The fisherman who discovers him and benefits from his bounty could later learn that the fish and birds of the ocean will only survive if he puts the genie back inside the bottle.

Little Emerald Ryding-Hoode and her granny could try to save an endangered wolf.

Prince Pobblebonk could warn a prissy princess about the dangers of poisoning the waterways. Juzzy could steal a golden egg-laying goose from a very tall man who lives at the top of a beanstalk, and be put to work in an organic garden for the next three years.

Research scientist turned children's illustrator, Gay McKinnon
Research scientist turned children’s illustrator, Gay McKinnon

Three Little Porkies could find out about renewable energy sources from the Big Bad Wolf.

And Cool Girl (Snow White) could have sensational time singing, gardening, cooking and preserving garden produce with seven short, but very talented brothers.

After their many trials and tribulations, all my protagonists could do their best to live sustainably ever after (most of the time anyway.)

The Smallest Carbon Footprint in the Land & Other Ecotales can be ordered through bookstores or from the publishers’ website, or contact sales@ipoz.biz.

2 thoughts on “On Fracturing Fairy Tales


  1. I found this while searching for writer’s retreats in Tasmania, and the post caught my attention because I also write twisted fairytales (among other things).

    “Cinderella Grows a Spine”, in which the protagonist realises that she has other options and rescues herself, is probably the best-selling of my books. It’s also the first in a series, followed by “Snow White Learns Stranger Danger”, “Red Riding Hood and the Stalker”, and “Beautiful, Inside and Out”.

    I agree that fairytales are excellent, but a product of a different time. Children of today need different messages.


    1. Hi Natasja-Rose, thanks for endorsing the value of fractured fairy tales. Good luck with your stories. Anne.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *